Dallas - "Old Red" Courthouse Boston - John Adams Courthouse New York State Supreme Court Building Los Angeles - Stanley Mosk Courthouse Honolulu - First Circuit Courthouse
When the Case Turns
on the Science

Judges and juries do not have to be scientists to decide whether an expert’s opinion is reliable. They have to be shown how the opinion was reached. That is the work: preparing and presenting the scientific evidence in toxic tort cases.

For more than twenty-five years we have defended companies against claims that their products caused disease. The evidence is the epidemiology, the pathology, the exposure science, and the methodology behind the opinions on both sides.

Most of our work has involved asbestos. We have also worked on cosmetic talc, solvents, silica, and crumb rubber. The substance changes. The question does not — what does the evidence establish about the dose alleged and the disease claimed?

TRIALS

We try these cases. No one hears a week of testimony without forming impressions. The defense case begins in the first week.

At trial →

EXPERT EVIDENCE

We serve as expert evidence counsel across a company’s docket. Cases tried by different firms in different courts still ask the same scientific questions.

The work →

BANKRUPTCY ESTIMATION

We represent the debtor on the scientific merits of asbestos claims. A settlement history records what a company paid, not what its product caused.

Bankruptcy Estimation →

THE RECORD

Garlock — Trial counsel through the 2000s, and on the scientific merits in its chapter 11 estimation proceeding. The court found Garlock’s settlement history an unreliable measure of its liability and held that $125 million is sufficient to satisfy its liability for the legitimate present and future mesothelioma claims against it, compared with the claimants’ representatives’ estimate of more than $1 billion. In re Garlock Sealing Technologies, LLC, 504 B.R. 71, 73–74 (Bankr. W.D.N.C. 2014).

What the court found about the products:

It is clear that Garlock’s products resulted in a relatively low exposure to asbestos to a limited population and that its legal responsibility for causing mesothelioma is relatively de minimis. 504 B.R. at 73.

Read: Garlock Estimation: A Science Case →

Georgia-Pacific and Bestwall — Expert evidence counsel to Georgia-Pacific in its asbestos litigation from 2014 to 2017, and special litigation counsel to Bestwall LLC in its chapter 11 proceedings in the Western District of North Carolina since 2017. In Rockman v. Union Carbide Corp., 266 F. Supp. 3d 839, 848, 854 (D. Md. 2017), the court excluded the plaintiffs’ specific-causation opinions and entered summary judgment for Georgia-Pacific.